Skip to main content

Frequently asked questions

Get answers to common questions about copyright, patents, and trademarks from our attorneys.

Patents

Patents give you the exclusive right to your inventions, so others cannot make, use, or sell them without your permission.

What is a U.S. patent?

A patent is a grant of an exclusive property right by the federal government to the inventor to exclude others from importing, making, using or selling the invention in the U.S. There are three main types of patent:

  • Utility patent covers new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or compositions of matter (such as chemical compositions and compounds), or any subsequent new and useful improvement.
  • Design patent covers new, original and ornamental design for an article of manufacture, and it is only the ornamental appearance of the article that is protected.
  • Plant patent covers a distinct and new variety of plant that has been reproduced asexually. Generally all inventions must be novel, and non-obvious to those skilled in that particular discipline in order to qualify for patent protection. For a utility patent, the invention must also be useful.
How long is a U.S. patent valid for and how many times can one renew it?

A utility patent is now valid for a term of 20 years from the U.S. patent application filing date, while a design patent is valid for a term of 14 years from the date of patent issuance. Generally a patent is not renewable except for extremely rare special circumstances. After the expiration of the patent term, the patent owner loses the exclusive patent rights to the invention.

Who may obtain a patent?

Only the true original inventor, or his authorized representative such as an assignee or licensee, may file a patent application for the invention.

What are non-patentable subject matters?

A patent cannot be obtained on simply an idea or suggestion, without actually putting it into practice. However, in recent years contrary to earlier rulings, the USPTO has accepted computer software and computer programs to be patentable subject matter. Also, since 1998 computer business models were upheld by the Court of Appeals of the Federal Circuit to be patentable subject matter.

How can an inventor profit from the invention?

The inventor may sell his ownership interest (or title) in the invention to anyone through assignment, and the inventor may receive either a lump sum payment, and/or a royalty payment based on the future sales of the invention by the assignee. Frequently an inventor may want to keep the title to the patent but allow others to use the invention through the grant of a patent license in exchange for a fixed fee or in conjunction with royalty payments. Large companies with significant patent portfolio and/or exposure to patent infringement lawsuits frequently have complicated cross-licensing agreements with other companies. Patent licensing is a complicated matter and it is recommended for an inventor to consult with a professional (such as a registered patent attorney) early on regarding assignments and licensing of the invention.

What is the address of the U.S. Patent Office?

The mailing address of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) is:

Commissioner of Patents and Trademarks
Washington, DC 20231

Form more information visit the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office https://www.uspto.gov/

What is Pat. Pend. or Patent Pending?

After the inventor has submitted a patent application to the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) the inventor may insert the notice 'patent pending' or 'patent applied for' onto the invention and accompanying material (such as brochures) to inform the public and potential infringers that a patent application for the invention is on file at the USPTO.

Can one use a U.S. patent to enforce against infringers worldwide?

No. A U.S. patent is valid only within the United States and if one would like to have patent rights and protection in other countries, the owner will need to file the patent in those countries, which generally is a very expensive process. For example, it is not uncommon for a Japanese patent to issue after four years of prosecution, at a cost of well in excess of $50,000.

When must an inventor file a patent application?

In most countries outside the U.S., any public disclosure of the invention (such as public sale or offer to sell, or published in a journal) prior to filing the patent application will render the inventor to forfeit all rights to apply for a patent.

  • Generally, in the U.S., there is a grace period of one year from the date of public disclosure whereby the inventor has to file for the application. One of the main reasons for such a one year period is to provide small inventors an opportunity to market the invention to determine whether it is feasible to obtain patent protection.
  • However, most other countries do not have such leniency toward small inventors. Therefore, a U.S. inventor who would want to obtain foreign patent should NOT make any public disclosure until the patent application has been filed at the USPTO. It is recommended an inventor consult a registered patent attorney regarding patent application filing requirements and deadlines.
When can a U.S. inventor apply for patent protection outside the United States?

A U.S. inventor may file patent application in other countries either after obtaining a foreign filing license from the USPTO, or after six months from the U.S. patent application filing date.

What is a PCT application?

A PCT application is an international application filed under the Patent Cooperation Treaty (the "PCT"). It allows you to designate any or all PCT contracting states and simultaneously seek patent protection in each of a large number of countries.

Advantages of filing a PCT application:

  • Allows you to evaluate your chances of protecting your invention before incurring major costs in foreign countries.
  • Keeps all of your options open for protecting your invention while still investigating its commercial possibilities abroad. Usually gives you an extra 18 months more in which to file in designated foreign Offices.
  • Obtains more reliable patents abroad.
  • Basic PCT facts - This will take you to the WIPO PCT Web Site (PDF)
  • Claiming priority
  • PCT contracting states
How do I claim the priority of an earlier application?

In an international patent application, you may claim the priority, under the Paris Convention-and to a certain extent within the framework of the World Trade Organization, of an earlier patent application for the same invention, whether it was a national, a regional (for example, European) or an international (PCT) application, for up to 12 months after the filing of that earlier application. If you do not claim priority from an earlier application, the priority date will be the international filing date of the international application (http://www.wipo.org/pct/en/).

What is Foreign National Phase?
  • Whether going through the PCT route or directly filing with individual foreign countries, the applicant must fulfill national requirements which differ for each country chosen.
  • The process is expensive and fees vary according to each country.
  • Timeline:
    • Direct: usually must file in a foreign country within one year of the priority filing date. E.g. if a US application is filed on 01/01/2002, the foreign national phase must be entered by 01/01/2003.
    • PCT: must file within 30 months from the priority filing date. This gives the applicant another 18 months to enter foreign national phase.
  • Most countries require absolute novelty. Therefore, inventors should NOT make any public disclosure of the invention, including offers to sell, until a US application has been filed.
What is the difference between a registered patent attorney or agent and an attorney not registered before the patent office?

In order to become registered before the USPTO, an attorney or agent must demonstrate that he possesses certain academic credentials in science and engineering, pass a moral character investigation and also pass a very rigorous examination relating to patent laws and patent examination procedures. Only registered patent attorneys and agents may practice before the USPTO on patent matters.

What are invention promotion firms and how can they help an inventor to market the products?

Invention promotion firms generally claim to assist inventors to promote the product and help them find venture capital or manufacturers that have the resources to put the invention into mass production and onto retail store shelves. There are many invention promotion firms that promise inventors special access to independent manufacturers looking for new product. It is recommended for an inventor to obtain clear answers to the following questions before engaging an invention promotion firm:

  1. What will be the TOTAL cost of its services?
  2. What criteria and system of review does the invention promotion firm use to determine whether an invention is worth pursuing?
  3. Who are the firm's invention evaluators and what are their qualifications?
  4. What are the names of the manufacturers and/or inventors with whom they have prior working relationships to provide references?
  5. What are the firm's success and rejection rates?

It is also recommended that one should investigate the firm before making any commitments, by contacting the local Chamber of Commerce, Better Business Bureau (BBB) , consumer protection agency, or Attorney General Office to learn if these organizations have received prior complaints on this firm.

The U.S. Federal Trade Commission has a booklet designed for consumers and inventors on the subject of Invention Promotion Firms. One may obtain a copy from any of their regional offices, or contact IPLG.

Trademarks

Trademarks protect the names, logos, and brands that identify your business and set it apart from competitors.

What is a trademark?

A trademark is any name, logo, shape, color, sound or even smell which is used to send a message to attract potential customers and distinguishes the source of goods from those of others. Any business that uses a name, in advertising or on its web page to attract its customers or identify its goods has entered the realm of trademark law.

Can one register a domain name or web address as a trademark?

Yes. As long as the domain name or web address is used in commerce to identify the source of goods or services. Therefore, by simply reserving the name with a web name registry such as INTERNIC, and posting of a web site, without associating that same name in selling goods and/or services will not be considered sufficient use in commerce for the mark to be registered.

What is the difference between a U.S. federal and a state trademark?

A state trademark registration allows a registrant to enforce his rights against all subsequent users of the name within the state, while a federal trademark is effective throughout the 50 United States. It is recommended that a federal trademark registration be filed if there are sales conducted across state lines or outside the United States.

Why should one conduct a search when the trademark office does one anyway?

The search performed by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) is generally limited to marks that are previously filed or registered under the federal registry. Marks that are registered under any of the fifty states' registries, or have earlier common law usage (such as fictitious business names filed with local governments) that may create conflict with the later chosen mark are frequently not revealed. Therefore, it is possible that even after one obtained a federal trademark registration from the USPTO, it may be cancelled in the future when it turns out that a prior entity has been using the same mark for a similar product or service in the same geographic location.

Must the trademark be used prior to filing the U.S. trademark application?

No. In the United States, one can file an Intent-to-Use (or commonly referred to as ITU) trademark application based on one's actual intent to use the mark in the near future.

How long does the U.S. federal trademark registration process take?

Normally from 15-28 months, depending on the number of refusals as noted by the examiner, and the number of oppositions filed by third parties after publication. Of course, an opposed mark may take a lot longer depending on the parties' financial resources, merits of the case and the parties' willingness to settle.

How long is a U.S. federal trademark registration valid for?

A U.S. federal trademark registration is valid for ten years from the registration date in the U.S. The registration is renewable upon payment of renewal fees and satisfying various statutory requirements. For example, failure to file a statement of continued use between the fifth and sixth year after the registration date may result in an abandonment of the mark.

What is the difference between a word mark and a design mark, such as a logo?

A word mark generally provides the broadest coverage, and prevents others from using the same name on the same products in both non-stylized (block letters mark) or stylized (script or design logo) manner. A design mark prohibits others from using a logo containing similar design elements that may be confusing to potential customers purchasing similar products.

Can a user put the company name, logo and slogan all in one trademark application?

No. This is because, a name, a logo and a slogan are all separate trademarks, and each application is limited to cover only one trademark.

What is the difference between the symbols TM, SM or ® and how are they used?

In the U.S., TM (trademark) and SM (service mark) symbols denote that the owner treats the name as a trademark or service mark respectively - they do not represent that the mark is on file at the trademark office. ® symbol denotes that the mark is a U.S. federally registered trademark. Only a mark that has been registered at the USPTO may use the ® symbol. Premature use of the ® symbol is considered deceptive and may result in a mark being refused registration. It is recommended that the TM (or SM) symbol be applied on new names even before an application is filed because this will give notice to the public and establish the owner's intention to treat this name, slogan or logo as a trademark.

What is the difference between trademarks and service marks?

Marks used on goods are called trademarks, and marks used to identify services are called service marks. Generally, a trademark for goods appears on the product or on its packaging, while a service mark appears in advertising of the services (such as stationary). Both trademarks and service marks are commonly referred to as trademarks. Frequently, a mark may serve as both a trademark and a service mark.

What are the most common refusals an applicant receives in a federal trademark application?

Some of the most common substantive refusals which a party may encounter are:

  • a. Likelihood of Confusion
  • b. Mere Descriptiveness
  • c. Generic Word
  • d. Indefinite Description

In a likelihood of confusion rejection, the examiner has found prior filed or registered marks that are either identical or confusingly similar in the Federal registry. In order to prevail, an applicant must show that the mark is dissimilar, or if the marks are similar, that the respective goods or services in question are too different to be confused.

In a mere descriptiveness rejection, the examiner has found that a mark is descriptive of the product, therefore the applicant should not be allowed exclusive use of the mark. The applicant will then have to prove that recognition by the relevant public or consumer, or "secondary meaning" has been established in this name, i.e. being well known in its industry, through many years of continued sales and through advertising.

In a generic word rejection, the examiner has found that the mark is simply the generic description of the product (instead of the source), and the applicant should be denied rights because the term is simply generic. For example, choosing the name APPLE for the mark of an apple fruit stand would be considered generic. The rationale is that if the applicant is allowed exclusive use of a generic term, then the general public and competitors will not be able to compete effectively because they cannot use the generic term of the product in their name (e.g. Abe's Apple company would not be able to use the word APPLE in its name or to identify the fruit if "apple" had been registered to others for an apple fruit stand.)

In an indefinite description rejection, the examiner has found that the terms used to describe the goods and/or services identifed in the trademark application to be too broad or unclear. Frequently an examiner will attempt to provide more definite terms to assist the applicant. For example, the term "computer software" by itself would be considered indefinite, and a more proper term would be "computer software in the field of business accounting."

What are the obligations of a trademark owner?

The obligations of a trademark owner are many. They include:

1. Maintaining documentation to prove when the mark was first used in commerce.
2. Continue using the trademark properly.
3. Policing the usage of the mark in the marketplace.
4. Filing the required statements in a timely manner and renewing the mark prior to expiration.